King Arthur Flour and Some Holiday Cookie Cutter Cookies For You

By Posted on 2 min read 318 views




ell this year I continued in what just may become an annual Christmas Eve ritual and I made butter cookie cutter cookies. Last year was the first year I did this, I thought it would be complicated—like you had to be Martha Stewart or a professional baker to pull this off. But it was easier then I thought. I was encouraged after making homemade biscotti which was not difficult either. The recipe was easy to follow and I was able to complete it in one day. However, the dough has to sit in the refrigerator for at least two hours and then it has to sit out for about 30 to 45 minutes to become soft enough to work with, so start early. The recipe says to “quickly” add the flour to the butter mixture, but there was nothing quick about it. It took me about twenty minutes to do this. They also say to not over work the dough in this final step as it can make the dough greasy and brittle. Last year I did not leave the butter out before I started, and yup I didn’t have time to do it this year either, so I popped the butter in the microwave for about 20 seconds, this definitely made the second step much easier. The final step before popping the cookies into the oven is brushing them with egg yolk for shine. Personally though, I did not like how the cookies looked with the egg yolk on them, so I skipped that step this time. I think they look fine with a matte finish and I thought the egg yolk was too noticeable when I tried this last year.


The options are endless as far as how to decorate the cookies. I love chocolate so I dipped the cookies in chocolate, but you can also ice them, or use sprinkles, it is up to you, and what you fancy. I actually made icing this year and iced some of the cookies, but this does take some expertise. I was not super happy with how the icing looked so I doused the cookies in powdered sugar to offset my less then spectacular efforts. You can follow this recipe from King Arthur Flour, it is almost exactly the same as the one I used—except for one thing. The King Arthur Flour recipe calls for a quarter teaspoon of extract or flavor of your choice, but the recipe I used called for the rind of one lemon, and I think it is this secret ingredient that made these cookies absolutely de-lish. So if you are feeling adventures go on and give it a whirl, I think you will be super proud with the results.

All images by ALLIE NYC© please do not use without permission and or crediting/linking back to



  • Kathleen
    December 29, 2014

    These look so delicious! What a fun new tradition 🙂

  • Jackie Harrison
    December 29, 2014

    King Arthur my favorite flour also love their website to get other baking goodies.

  • Rachelle
    December 29, 2014

    hope you had a great Christmas girly, and these look sooooo delicious.


  • Dressed2dNines
    December 29, 2014

    Awww that’s an awesome tradition! Looks delicious!

  • Kim of A Very Sweet Blog
    December 29, 2014

    Allie, you are an excellent baker. These cookies look so good! I love their shapes and how you dipped them in chocolate. WTG

  • Lady Lilith
    December 29, 2014

    The cookies look great. Very professional.

  • Daphne
    December 29, 2014

    I had never thought to dip the top of heart cookies in chocolate before! I always go half and half. They look really lovely.

  • Renfashionista
    December 29, 2014

    Hey, didn’t know you’re such a chef!;-) The cookies look cute! I LOVE baking! I bake a cake a week and believe it or not, eat it all by myself and ALWAYS eat a piece of cake for breakfast! 🙂 Have a blast and HAPPY NEW YEAR 2015!
    Toast your Purse with an Outfit!
    Fashion Advice, Events and More

  • 365hangers
    December 29, 2014

    Those cookies look so yummy, we want all the chocolate dipped ones!!! Definitely giving that at try. xx

  • K / Pure & Complex
    December 30, 2014

    These cookie are so darn cute. I am so loving this post. I hope you had a great holiday

  • Akaleistar
    December 30, 2014

    What a delicious tradition!

  • Denise
    December 30, 2014

    These look so delicious! Thanks so much for sharing!


  • Jeann
    December 30, 2014

    Wow! lovely indeed, you can really bake huh? Am not so much into baking cookies but cakes I don’t mind though:))

    Hope you had a great Christmas celebration, Allie! You are making me so hungry here already looking at these lovely pictures of yours *_^

    Big hugs,

  • Rachel
    December 30, 2014

    These cookies look super yummy! I will have to try, but I will probably eat them all myself 😛

    Rachel xx

  • Monica
    December 30, 2014

    Look so delicious!:) They are really easy to make. I make these cookies every year. Sometimes when I have a little more time, I make them with nutella or marmalade filling.

  • Ashley
    December 30, 2014

    These look yummy! 🙂

    Le Stylo Rouge

  • Mree
    December 30, 2014

    They look so yummie!!

  • Monika
    January 2, 2015

    So pretty! xx

A Michael Kors Parker, a warm fuzzy hat, and a Day at the Park
King Arthur Flour and Some Holiday Cookie Cutter Cookies For You